Is the Nyingma tradition profoundly non-monastic?
Re: Is the Nyingma tradition profoundly non-monastic?
@ Jkhedrup
I did not have the impression that you were engaging us in debate on the role of monasticism in the Nyingma tradition.
Rather, it seemed, you are immersed, steeped in a culture that assumes that to some extent assumes that
monasticism is normative and you are questioning that assumption. It doesn't seem to be the case with us, why is that?
Is the view that we are mainly non-monastic faulty? Is there some other way of understanding the culture of the
Nyingma community?
I think that the point of confusion is that we have two sanghas, red and white, who have parity, And that the ngakpas
hold higher vows causes has us hold them in higher esteem. But if course, like monastics some don't really live up to
their commitments-- and this should be expected because these to paths are practices not results. We also honor the
capacity of laypeople who are not clergy, but still possessed of Buddhanature, and are qualified to accomplish high realization.
I think that raising such questions produces understanding. Formal debate has more chance of inflaming know-it-all-ism,
in my opinion.
I did not have the impression that you were engaging us in debate on the role of monasticism in the Nyingma tradition.
Rather, it seemed, you are immersed, steeped in a culture that assumes that to some extent assumes that
monasticism is normative and you are questioning that assumption. It doesn't seem to be the case with us, why is that?
Is the view that we are mainly non-monastic faulty? Is there some other way of understanding the culture of the
Nyingma community?
I think that the point of confusion is that we have two sanghas, red and white, who have parity, And that the ngakpas
hold higher vows causes has us hold them in higher esteem. But if course, like monastics some don't really live up to
their commitments-- and this should be expected because these to paths are practices not results. We also honor the
capacity of laypeople who are not clergy, but still possessed of Buddhanature, and are qualified to accomplish high realization.
I think that raising such questions produces understanding. Formal debate has more chance of inflaming know-it-all-ism,
in my opinion.
Re: Is the Nyingma tradition profoundly non-monastic?
In Buddhist culture monasticism is normative, and when it comes to vows the monks and nuns definitely have the upper hand.ngodrup wrote:...a culture that assumes that to some extent assumes that monasticism is normative...the ngakpas hold higher vows causes has us hold them in higher esteem.
R.
Re: Is the Nyingma tradition profoundly non-monastic?
Please read it. "A Gem of Many Colors" is probably the most excellent recent namthar available.Yeti wrote:I haven't read it, can you please explain a little.JKhedrup wrote:Sometimes the institutions are what preserve the texts and lineages that let the yogi/nis wander off and gain those realizations....However, you see for example in Jamgon Kongtrul's biography that in some cases they can be obstacles.
A faction of monks from HE Jamgon Kongtrul's institution turned against him in part and created a separation between him and the 8th (?) Tai Situpa - a tulku whose bittersweet story can be found in the excellent "Enthronement: The Recognition Of The Reincarnate Masters Of Tibet And The Himalayas" - Jamgon Kongtrul wrote an explanation of the tulku phenomena for lay and junior monastic Tibetans to be read during the enthronement ceremony and prayers for the enthronement ceremony (these are translated in the book as well). Kongtrul doesn't really write about the split that much but it comes up in his autobiography over a several year period.
In part, Kongtrul's devotion to his retreat program was partly a result of this split.
Kirt Undercoffer
“Where do atomic bombs come from?”
Zen Master Seung Sahn said, “That’s simple. Atomic bombs come from the mind that likes this and doesn’t like that.”
"Even if you practice only for an hour a day with faith and inspiration, good qualities will steadily increase. Regular practice makes it easy to transform your mind. From seeing only relative truth, you will eventually reach a profound certainty in the meaning of absolute truth."
Kyabje Dilgo Khyentse Rinpoche.
"Only you can make your mind beautiful."
HH Chetsang Rinpoche
Zen Master Seung Sahn said, “That’s simple. Atomic bombs come from the mind that likes this and doesn’t like that.”
"Even if you practice only for an hour a day with faith and inspiration, good qualities will steadily increase. Regular practice makes it easy to transform your mind. From seeing only relative truth, you will eventually reach a profound certainty in the meaning of absolute truth."
Kyabje Dilgo Khyentse Rinpoche.
"Only you can make your mind beautiful."
HH Chetsang Rinpoche
Re: Is the Nyingma tradition profoundly non-monastic?
Was this Old Dilgo Khyentse or his recent tulku?Yeti wrote: I once had the good fortune of being able to listen to a teaching on the nature of mind by Dilgo Khyentse Rinpoche.
Maybe he was excited. One hopes that we aren't producing Geshe Tsagphupa's (the geshe who was jealous of Milarepa).For those of us who didn't understand Tibetan we just sat there and tried to be as present as possible during that teaching. There was a western Geshe there, quite fluent in Tibetan. Whilst all the other Nyingmas sat there and tried to take the teaching as directly as possible, the western Geshe was rocking backwards and forwards vigorously whilst counting points with one hand on the finger of the other.
Kirt
“Where do atomic bombs come from?”
Zen Master Seung Sahn said, “That’s simple. Atomic bombs come from the mind that likes this and doesn’t like that.”
"Even if you practice only for an hour a day with faith and inspiration, good qualities will steadily increase. Regular practice makes it easy to transform your mind. From seeing only relative truth, you will eventually reach a profound certainty in the meaning of absolute truth."
Kyabje Dilgo Khyentse Rinpoche.
"Only you can make your mind beautiful."
HH Chetsang Rinpoche
Zen Master Seung Sahn said, “That’s simple. Atomic bombs come from the mind that likes this and doesn’t like that.”
"Even if you practice only for an hour a day with faith and inspiration, good qualities will steadily increase. Regular practice makes it easy to transform your mind. From seeing only relative truth, you will eventually reach a profound certainty in the meaning of absolute truth."
Kyabje Dilgo Khyentse Rinpoche.
"Only you can make your mind beautiful."
HH Chetsang Rinpoche
Re: Is the Nyingma tradition profoundly non-monastic?
I would second the opinion that this is one of the best namthars available in English--Kongtrul really broke with the namthar model and talked frankly about his life.kirtu wrote:Please read it. "A Gem of Many Colors" is probably the most excellent recent namthar available.Yeti wrote:I haven't read it, can you please explain a little.JKhedrup wrote:Sometimes the institutions are what preserve the texts and lineages that let the yogi/nis wander off and gain those realizations....However, you see for example in Jamgon Kongtrul's biography that in some cases they can be obstacles.
A faction of monks from HE Jamgon Kongtrul's institution turned against him in part and created a separation between him and the 8th (?) Tai Situpa - a tulku whose bittersweet story can be found in the excellent "Enthronement: The Recognition Of The Reincarnate Masters Of Tibet And The Himalayas" - Jamgon Kongtrul wrote an explanation of the tulku phenomena for lay and junior monastic Tibetans to be read during the enthronement ceremony and prayers for the enthronement ceremony (these are translated in the book as well). Kongtrul doesn't really write about the split that much but it comes up in his autobiography over a several year period.
In part, Kongtrul's devotion to his retreat program was partly a result of this split.
Kirt Undercoffer
Kangtrul's deep regret at having set down his Nyingma practice to move into Institutionalized Kagyu mold, and the consequent creation of the Rime model, really transformed Tibetan Buddhism. Without it, we would not have the Kalu Rinpoche's crew of non-sectarian translators and who have brought us so much of the rich literature in translation that we have today, to touch on the very tip of the iceberg. I don't know where the Nyingma and Kagyu traditions would be without Kongtrul today.
A strict monk and scholar!
Re: Is the Nyingma tradition profoundly non-monastic?
I agree. I am a huge fan of the Tsadra series. The Tsadra series and Lam Rim Chenmo tie for best quality of translated material in modern English in my opinion. If I had the money I would purchase the entire series, along with all the volumes of Kongtrul's Treasury of Knowledge, translated by what is now called the Kalu Rinpoche Translation Group.
Re: Is the Nyingma tradition profoundly non-monastic?
Not only that, but Kalu Rinpoche's crew have translated much of the Padma Publishing,Jnanasukha Foundation, Vajrayana Foundation translations, as well as translating the whole Shangpa lineage tradition, and they have been involved in European translation projects as well. It just goes on and on, and the personal sacrifice of that group has been immense.
Re: Is the Nyingma tradition profoundly non-monastic?
One of the things I really like about it as well is that it is very clearly a "team". This is really what we need with translation endeavours in the West. Both for quality control purposes and cohesion purposes. It is really a shame more endeavours are not consultative.
Re: Is the Nyingma tradition profoundly non-monastic?
Most of the sangha I know and connect with do not visit or post on Internet forums because of this. They wisely stay away because of what you observe. So maybe it is worth looking offline for more no sectarian influence to try to get a balanced view. At the same time, a lot of people here are no sectarian, but maybe that goes under the radar.JKhedrup wrote:Thanks Raksha for your comments.
Yeti-laThis high alert attitude comes from seeing what happens on the various internet forums. The anonymity and accessbility of the internet means that attitudes that people would not normally express face-to-face in polite company often appear in the forums. I think if you stick around here awhile and observe you will see some of what I mean. I agree that in the centres people are generally milder, though I definitely think the sectarianism still exists.I'm just wondering how my quick remark set you off, maybe your radar is set on too high alert for this. Maybe it's not. I don't know
We all feel pressure to uphold the Dharma, and that's a good thing. I personally feel that whilst HHDL is alive and with us he deflects sooooo much negativity that could be directed to us because of His incredible manifestation and example. Goodness, even Guru Rinpoche was burnt (attempted), had forces attack Him, etc, etc.... so why should we expect the path is going to be easy for us when we have far less wisdom and merit???
"People are fond of saying all sorts of things about others behind their backs, mentioning their names again and again. Instead of slandering others in this way, “slander” the yidam: utter his name repeatedly by reciting his mantra all the time." - Dilgo Khyentse Rinpoche - Zurchungpa’s Testament - Shambhala Publications
Re: Is the Nyingma tradition profoundly non-monastic?
I'll try, if I can find a digital version. My sight is going and more and more I can only read on a large computer screen in large font. And more and more my vision is shaky as my nervous system deteriorates. (pls don't feel sorry for me... my life contains great fortune, and the funny thing is, as such situations compound on themselves there's the ever present Dharma teachers in the sky above me say "We told you so"... that's the great thing about the Dharma, it tells us straight about the nature of phenomena... Lion's Roar:)Please read it. "A Gem of Many Colors" is probably the most excellent recent namthar available.
A faction of monks from HE Jamgon Kongtrul's institution turned against him in part and created a separation between him and the 8th (?) Tai Situpa - a tulku whose bittersweet story can be found in the excellent "Enthronement: The Recognition Of The Reincarnate Masters Of Tibet And The Himalayas" - Jamgon Kongtrul wrote an explanation of the tulku phenomena for lay and junior monastic Tibetans to be read during the enthronement ceremony and prayers for the enthronement ceremony (these are translated in the book as well). Kongtrul doesn't really write about the split that much but it comes up in his autobiography over a several year period.
In part, Kongtrul's devotion to his retreat program was partly a result of this split.
Kirt Undercoffer
Fortunately I did a lot of my Dharma reading back in the 70's and 80's when I could read a lot, but there are so many good translations out there now.
Anyway, it seems to be one that is worth the effort. Thanks.
"People are fond of saying all sorts of things about others behind their backs, mentioning their names again and again. Instead of slandering others in this way, “slander” the yidam: utter his name repeatedly by reciting his mantra all the time." - Dilgo Khyentse Rinpoche - Zurchungpa’s Testament - Shambhala Publications
Re: Is the Nyingma tradition profoundly non-monastic?
I'm not sure I understand you, but I think I disagree with you here. Everyone in Tibetan Buddhism--monastic and non-monastic-- takes empowerment, so we all receive the tantric vows. Very few people in this world are even holding one tantric vow purely -- having completely pure view of our lama all the time. I know I lapse. This is not even mentioning the many others -- even among the primary, core, samayas that most of us oh-so-holy holy ngakpa/mass and naljyorpa/ma's don't keep in mind in the slightest.ngodrup wrote:@ Jkhedrup
...I think that the point of confusion is that we have two sanghas, red and white, who have parity, And that the ngakpas
hold higher vows causes has us hold them in higher esteem. But if course, like monastics some don't really live up to
their commitments-- and this should be expected because these to paths are practices not results. We also honor the
capacity of laypeople who are not clergy, but still possessed of Buddhanature, and are qualified to accomplish high realization.
And so, I can't say that we are are upholders of tantric samayas, anymore than monks and nuns are. Therefore, I do not hold anyone in higher esteem based on the color of their robes. People who practice softly and genuinely, with deep humility, stand out in crowd--like they are in color in a black and white film. They're the one's I hold in high esteem.
Re: Is the Nyingma tradition profoundly non-monastic?
Was Dilgo Khyentse Rinpoche at Chanteloube, France in July/August 1986.kirtu wrote:Was this Old Dilgo Khyentse or his recent tulku?Yeti wrote: I once had the good fortune of being able to listen to a teaching on the nature of mind by Dilgo Khyentse Rinpoche.
Actually I think he was incredibly inspired by the teaching he was hearing, but to me, that manifest in what I would call an inspired Gelug way. I don't think he was suffering any kleshas at all. He was as inspired by anyone else there, maybe more than most of us as he was fluent in Tibetan, but the way it manifest was such a contrast in styles. Nothing wrong. It was just an interesting observation. I explained this a little more in other posts to JKhendrup.Maybe he was excited. One hopes that we aren't producing Geshe Tsagphupa's (the geshe who was jealous of Milarepa).For those of us who didn't understand Tibetan we just sat there and tried to be as present as possible during that teaching. There was a western Geshe there, quite fluent in Tibetan. Whilst all the other Nyingmas sat there and tried to take the teaching as directly as possible, the western Geshe was rocking backwards and forwards vigorously whilst counting points with one hand on the finger of the other.
Kirt
"People are fond of saying all sorts of things about others behind their backs, mentioning their names again and again. Instead of slandering others in this way, “slander” the yidam: utter his name repeatedly by reciting his mantra all the time." - Dilgo Khyentse Rinpoche - Zurchungpa’s Testament - Shambhala Publications
Re: Is the Nyingma tradition profoundly non-monastic?
Yudron wrote:I'm not sure I understand you, but I think I disagree with you here. Everyone in Tibetan Buddhism--monastic and non-monastic-- takes empowerment, so we all receive the tantric vows. Very few people in this world are even holding one tantric vow purely -- having completely pure view of our lama all the time. I know I lapse. This is not even mentioning the many others -- even among the primary, core, samayas that most of us oh-so-holy holy ngakpa/mass and naljyorpa/ma's don't keep in mind in the slightest.ngodrup wrote:@ Jkhedrup
...I think that the point of confusion is that we have two sanghas, red and white, who have parity, And that the ngakpas
hold higher vows causes has us hold them in higher esteem. But if course, like monastics some don't really live up to
their commitments-- and this should be expected because these to paths are practices not results. We also honor the
capacity of laypeople who are not clergy, but still possessed of Buddhanature, and are qualified to accomplish high realization.
And so, I can't say that we are are upholders of tantric samayas, anymore than monks and nuns are. Therefore, I do not hold anyone in higher esteem based on the color of their robes. People who practice softly and genuinely, with deep humility, stand out in crowd--like they are in color in a black and white film. They're the one's I hold in high esteem.
Samaya's take a lot of conscious work IMHO. It's natural to lapse as samsara's habitual patterns continually arise, but for a practitioner, that is exactly what we are working on with the samayas and view, to wear down that habitual mind.
"People are fond of saying all sorts of things about others behind their backs, mentioning their names again and again. Instead of slandering others in this way, “slander” the yidam: utter his name repeatedly by reciting his mantra all the time." - Dilgo Khyentse Rinpoche - Zurchungpa’s Testament - Shambhala Publications
-
- Posts: 1292
- Joined: Tue Dec 15, 2009 3:19 am
- Location: Southern Oregon
Re: Is the Nyingma tradition profoundly non-monastic?
Ngodrup, you'd be hard-pressed to find a Nyingma monk or nun who hasn't received anuttarayogatantra empowerment... as as such, monks and nuns have even more vows than we "ngakpas" do. They have their hundreds of monastic vows PLUS all of our tantric samayas. And aside from the vow not to cut one's hair that comes with the hair empowerment of Troma Nagmo, there aren't any special, unique vows or samayas particular to "ngakpas." As such, all inner tantric practitioners are therefore ngakpas, if we're applying that label based upon vows.ngodrup wrote:
I think that the point of confusion is that we have two sanghas, red and white, who have parity, And that the ngakpas
hold higher vows causes has us hold them in higher esteem.
Pema Rigdzin/Brian Pittman
Re: Is the Nyingma tradition profoundly non-monastic?
There is a Kindle version (unfortunately only available through Amazon - I hope that Dharma publishing places produce more e-versions of various kinds). I have it and don't remember a problem with it (sometimes there are problems with the Kindle versions but I can only remember one problem with a math text). I expect that Kindle readers (the available software readers) under Windows or possibly Mac would be able to increase the font sufficiently. I have increasing poor vision and have increased my font size under the semi-authorized Windows version running under Wine under Linux. In fact I just brought it up (I had been reading Books 9 and 10 of Kongtrul's Encyclopedia Path and Goal) and it looks perfect.Yeti wrote:I'll try, if I can find a digital version.Please read it. "A Gem of Many Colors" is probably the most excellent
Kirt
“Where do atomic bombs come from?”
Zen Master Seung Sahn said, “That’s simple. Atomic bombs come from the mind that likes this and doesn’t like that.”
"Even if you practice only for an hour a day with faith and inspiration, good qualities will steadily increase. Regular practice makes it easy to transform your mind. From seeing only relative truth, you will eventually reach a profound certainty in the meaning of absolute truth."
Kyabje Dilgo Khyentse Rinpoche.
"Only you can make your mind beautiful."
HH Chetsang Rinpoche
Zen Master Seung Sahn said, “That’s simple. Atomic bombs come from the mind that likes this and doesn’t like that.”
"Even if you practice only for an hour a day with faith and inspiration, good qualities will steadily increase. Regular practice makes it easy to transform your mind. From seeing only relative truth, you will eventually reach a profound certainty in the meaning of absolute truth."
Kyabje Dilgo Khyentse Rinpoche.
"Only you can make your mind beautiful."
HH Chetsang Rinpoche
Re: Is the Nyingma tradition profoundly non-monastic?
Perfect. I'm very happy for you all all who attended.Yeti wrote:Was Dilgo Khyentse Rinpoche at Chanteloube, France in July/August 1986.kirtu wrote:Was this Old Dilgo Khyentse or his recent tulku?Yeti wrote: I once had the good fortune of being able to listen to a teaching on the nature of mind by Dilgo Khyentse Rinpoche.
I see. Perfect. Sorry about the misunderstanding.Actually I think he was incredibly inspired by the teaching he was hearing, but to me, that manifest in what I would call an inspired Gelug way. I don't think he was suffering any kleshas at all. He was as inspired by anyone else there, maybe more than most of us as he was fluent in Tibetan, but the way it manifest was such a contrast in styles. Nothing wrong. It was just an interesting observation.Maybe he was excited. One hopes that we aren't producing Geshe Tsagphupa's ....
Kirt
“Where do atomic bombs come from?”
Zen Master Seung Sahn said, “That’s simple. Atomic bombs come from the mind that likes this and doesn’t like that.”
"Even if you practice only for an hour a day with faith and inspiration, good qualities will steadily increase. Regular practice makes it easy to transform your mind. From seeing only relative truth, you will eventually reach a profound certainty in the meaning of absolute truth."
Kyabje Dilgo Khyentse Rinpoche.
"Only you can make your mind beautiful."
HH Chetsang Rinpoche
Zen Master Seung Sahn said, “That’s simple. Atomic bombs come from the mind that likes this and doesn’t like that.”
"Even if you practice only for an hour a day with faith and inspiration, good qualities will steadily increase. Regular practice makes it easy to transform your mind. From seeing only relative truth, you will eventually reach a profound certainty in the meaning of absolute truth."
Kyabje Dilgo Khyentse Rinpoche.
"Only you can make your mind beautiful."
HH Chetsang Rinpoche
Re: Is the Nyingma tradition profoundly non-monastic?
Yes, I have a number of ebooks on my Amazon account which I can read online. Can't download them, but reading online is fine. They have this book in Kindle format, so that is great.kirtu wrote:There is a Kindle version (unfortunately only available through Amazon - I hope that Dharma publishing places produce more e-versions of various kinds). I have it and don't remember a problem with it (sometimes there are problems with the Kindle versions but I can only remember one problem with a math text). I expect that Kindle readers (the available software readers) under Windows or possibly Mac would be able to increase the font sufficiently. I have increasing poor vision and have increased my font size under the semi-authorized Windows version running under Wine under Linux. In fact I just brought it up (I had been reading Books 9 and 10 of Kongtrul's Encyclopedia Path and Goal) and it looks perfect.Yeti wrote:I'll try, if I can find a digital version.Please read it. "A Gem of Many Colors" is probably the most excellent
Kirt
I use Linux too.
Thanks
"People are fond of saying all sorts of things about others behind their backs, mentioning their names again and again. Instead of slandering others in this way, “slander” the yidam: utter his name repeatedly by reciting his mantra all the time." - Dilgo Khyentse Rinpoche - Zurchungpa’s Testament - Shambhala Publications
Re: Is the Nyingma tradition profoundly non-monastic?
Yes, he's fine. It actually needs to be clear there was nothing bad or neurotic about this. He was a nice guy, and sat through other teachings just like the rest of us, but that teaching was obviously profound, and he was able to understand it, and he kind of went to town with that inspiration in a very Gelug inspired way.kirtu wrote:I see. Perfect. Sorry about the misunderstanding.Actually I think he was incredibly inspired by the teaching he was hearing, but to me, that manifest in what I would call an inspired Gelug way. I don't think he was suffering any kleshas at all. He was as inspired by anyone else there, maybe more than most of us as he was fluent in Tibetan, but the way it manifest was such a contrast in styles. Nothing wrong. It was just an interesting observation.
Kirt
As he was one of the first Western Geshe's the Gelugpa's made him go and do his Geshe debate at all three major Gelug monasteries before they would give him his Geshe degree. I think he's remained a pretty humble practitioner in the service of the Dharma ever since and not sort out any fame or fortune. I rejoice in his merit, I admire him, nice guy from what I remember.
"People are fond of saying all sorts of things about others behind their backs, mentioning their names again and again. Instead of slandering others in this way, “slander” the yidam: utter his name repeatedly by reciting his mantra all the time." - Dilgo Khyentse Rinpoche - Zurchungpa’s Testament - Shambhala Publications
-
- Posts: 33
- Joined: Wed Jan 04, 2012 12:03 pm
Re: Is the Nyingma tradition profoundly non-monastic?
[quote="Pema Rigdzin"
Hi Pema Rigdzin,
I was thinking about discussing a point very similar to yours but in the 'Contemporary Tertons' thread not this one. Either way I guess it will work in either. The tértön referenced in the dissertation in that thread, Déchen Ösel Dorje, who is a contemporary tértön, has revealed térmas which contain vows specific to ngakpa clothing and ornaments (I say ngakpa only because I can't recall whether or not ngakmas are invited into the system) and within that new system there are many items of clothing that the ordained ngakpa - following a ceremony where the vows are given - vows to wear during certain ritual occasions, as well as the vow to maintain uncut hair. I remember Malcolm pointing out that one can't speak of a ngakpa ordination per se because of there being no subsequent confession if one were to fail to wear one's ngakpa attire, as there is in the monastic ordination system. Now it seems that that may not be the case, and, this is the only system from which such information is publicly available.
I think it's perhaps useful to consider the possibility that vows in relation to tantric samaya (apart from the root vows I'd imagine) are not identical in different lineages and are not made public, and so some ngakpa lineages may be holding vows relating to the body apart from the hair vows, which because they are not public we may be unaware of.
The térmas of Déchen Ösel Dorje are interesting because they re-emphasise the dual branch history of the Nyingma, giving a specific and clearly delineated religious identity to the white sangha, although not as some sort of contradiction to the red sangha, simply as a defined alternative. One of the implications of such a térma system (and others perhaps) is that they include vows which are both tantric and ngkapa, so to speak, but that may not necessarily occur in tantric systems which are not explicitly ngakpa in orientation. If that is the case then it is possible that a ngapka should not necessarily be equated simply with a holder of inner tantra samaya but with ngakpa tantric samaya. Who knows, perhaps I'm overstating it, but it does as least look like a possibility. I've noticed also that there is more than one definition of a ngakpa, depending on who you ask, which is fine I guess but it does seem to cause some confusion.
All the best,
Alex.
Ngodrup, you'd be hard-pressed to find a Nyingma monk or nun who hasn't received anuttarayogatantra empowerment... as as such, monks and nuns have even more vows than we "ngakpas" do. They have their hundreds of monastic vows PLUS all of our tantric samayas. And aside from the vow not to cut one's hair that comes with the hair empowerment of Troma Nagmo, there aren't any special, unique vows or samayas particular to "ngakpas." As such, all inner tantric practitioners are therefore ngakpas, if we're applying that label based upon vows.
Hi Pema Rigdzin,
I was thinking about discussing a point very similar to yours but in the 'Contemporary Tertons' thread not this one. Either way I guess it will work in either. The tértön referenced in the dissertation in that thread, Déchen Ösel Dorje, who is a contemporary tértön, has revealed térmas which contain vows specific to ngakpa clothing and ornaments (I say ngakpa only because I can't recall whether or not ngakmas are invited into the system) and within that new system there are many items of clothing that the ordained ngakpa - following a ceremony where the vows are given - vows to wear during certain ritual occasions, as well as the vow to maintain uncut hair. I remember Malcolm pointing out that one can't speak of a ngakpa ordination per se because of there being no subsequent confession if one were to fail to wear one's ngakpa attire, as there is in the monastic ordination system. Now it seems that that may not be the case, and, this is the only system from which such information is publicly available.
I think it's perhaps useful to consider the possibility that vows in relation to tantric samaya (apart from the root vows I'd imagine) are not identical in different lineages and are not made public, and so some ngakpa lineages may be holding vows relating to the body apart from the hair vows, which because they are not public we may be unaware of.
The térmas of Déchen Ösel Dorje are interesting because they re-emphasise the dual branch history of the Nyingma, giving a specific and clearly delineated religious identity to the white sangha, although not as some sort of contradiction to the red sangha, simply as a defined alternative. One of the implications of such a térma system (and others perhaps) is that they include vows which are both tantric and ngkapa, so to speak, but that may not necessarily occur in tantric systems which are not explicitly ngakpa in orientation. If that is the case then it is possible that a ngapka should not necessarily be equated simply with a holder of inner tantra samaya but with ngakpa tantric samaya. Who knows, perhaps I'm overstating it, but it does as least look like a possibility. I've noticed also that there is more than one definition of a ngakpa, depending on who you ask, which is fine I guess but it does seem to cause some confusion.
All the best,
Alex.
-
- Posts: 1292
- Joined: Tue Dec 15, 2009 3:19 am
- Location: Southern Oregon
Re: Is the Nyingma tradition profoundly non-monastic?
Alex,
This is all interesting, but honestly, the inner tantric/HYT samayas of all the Nyingma and Sarma systems all come down to the same point: maintaining the view of the three vajras. From that point of view, any differences in the letter of these samayas between HYT systems is merely on an outer level; the spirit of the commitments is the same. At their essence, the samayas of each of these systems are all serving the function of facilitating awareness of the 3 vajras, and all practitioners of Anuttarayoga have this commitment whether monk, nun, ngakpa/ma, naljorpa/ma. It makes no difference. This is all the more so when we get into Dzogchen and Mahamudra territory.
Also, both Nyingma and Sarma tantras have many versions of prescriptions for adornment with various examples of fearless heruka attire, etc., at a certain advanced stage on the path of the two stages, so there's nothing new under the sun except some outward variation on the same essential points of conduct.
This is all interesting, but honestly, the inner tantric/HYT samayas of all the Nyingma and Sarma systems all come down to the same point: maintaining the view of the three vajras. From that point of view, any differences in the letter of these samayas between HYT systems is merely on an outer level; the spirit of the commitments is the same. At their essence, the samayas of each of these systems are all serving the function of facilitating awareness of the 3 vajras, and all practitioners of Anuttarayoga have this commitment whether monk, nun, ngakpa/ma, naljorpa/ma. It makes no difference. This is all the more so when we get into Dzogchen and Mahamudra territory.
Also, both Nyingma and Sarma tantras have many versions of prescriptions for adornment with various examples of fearless heruka attire, etc., at a certain advanced stage on the path of the two stages, so there's nothing new under the sun except some outward variation on the same essential points of conduct.
Pema Rigdzin/Brian Pittman