Several websites and books have proposed that "buddhatvam yosityonisamasritam" (or slight variants) are either the genuine words of the Buddha, or of later Tantric Buddhists.
The first claim is obviously false; while the second doesn't seem to have much basis in fact either.
The earliest source I've found for the quote is in de La Vallee-Poussin's 'Une Pratique des Tantres" (1897). He doesn't reference the text, however, though in the same passage of writing he does talk about the Candamaharosanatantra. This has led me to believe that he was misinterpreting chapter 10, verse 24: "caṇḍaroṣapadaṃ dṛṣṭvā yoṣidyonisamāśritam".
He's evidently a fine scholar; but fine scholars also make mistakes.
Anyone have any thoughts on this?
Looking for the source of a quote
General forum on the teachings of all schools of Mahayana and Vajrayana Buddhism. Topics specific to one school are best posted in the appropriate sub-forum.
Jump to
- Welcome
- ↳ TERMS OF SERVICE (including Reporting Procedures)
- ↳ Announcements
- ↳ Introductions
- ↳ Suggestion Box
- Bodhisattvacarya
- ↳ Mahāyāna Buddhism
- ↳ Tibetan Buddhism
- ↳ Dzogchen
- ↳ Nyingma
- ↳ Mahamudra
- ↳ Kagyu
- ↳ Sakya
- ↳ Gelug
- ↳ Jonang
- ↳ Chod
- ↳ Bön
- ↳ Buddhist Tantra Talk
- ↳ East Asian Buddhism
- ↳ Zen
- ↳ Chan
- ↳ Seon
- ↳ Rinzai
- ↳ Soto
- ↳ Thien
- ↳ Pure Land
- ↳ Jodo Shin Shu
- ↳ Tendai
- ↳ Nichiren
- ↳ Soka Gakkai/SGI
- ↳ Nichiren Shu
- ↳ Nichiren Shoshu
- ↳ Shingon
- ↳ Sūtra Studies
- ↳ Academic Discussion
- General Dharma
- ↳ Discovering Mahayana Buddhism
- ↳ Abhidharmakosabhasyam Book Club
- ↳ Dharma in Everyday Life
- ↳ Help Required
- ↳ Dharma Events
- ↳ North America (USA & Canada)
- ↳ Central & South America
- ↳ Europe
- ↳ Asia/Pacific
- ↳ Australia/NZ
- ↳ Africa
- ↳ Dharma Stories
- ↳ Shrine Room
- Upāya
- ↳ Meditation
- ↳ Ethical Conduct
- ↳ Engaged Buddhism
- ↳ Prayers and Aspirations
- ↳ Dāna for Dharma
- ↳ Wellness, Diet and Fitness
- ↳ Alternative Health
- ↳ Tibetan Medicine
- ↳ Dying and Death
- Teahouse of the Compassionate One
- ↳ Lounge
- ↳ Creative Writing
- ↳ Games & Humour
- ↳ Media
- ↳ Book Reviews
- ↳ Language
- ↳ Links to Other DW sites
- ↳ LINK TO: Dhamma Wheel Theravada Buddhism Forum
- ↳ LINK TO: Dharma Paths—Comparative Religion Forum
- ↳ LINK TO: Dhamma/Dharma Wiki - Buddhist encyclopedia