Garchen Rinpoche : The very nature of love is the Pure Land

Forum for discussion of Tibetan Buddhism. Questions specific to one school are best posted in the appropriate sub-forum.
Post Reply
Posts: 1486
Joined: Wed Oct 21, 2009 7:30 am

Garchen Rinpoche : The very nature of love is the Pure Land

Post by phantom59 » Thu Jul 26, 2012 12:34 pm

"The Subduer said that all the unbearable suffering of the three lower realms is the fruition of wrongdoing. Therefore, never committing negative deeds, even at peril to one's life, is the bodhisattvas' practice."

All the unbearable suffering of the lower realms is created by our afflictive emotions. The Buddha did not invent or create a certain belief, but rather, having realized how things really are, the Buddha compassionately explained what causes suffering and what causes happiness. He taught, "If you wish to be happy, this is what you need to do. If you wish to avoid suffering, this is what you must give up." "The very nature of hatred is hell. The very nature of love is the pure land." Hell is not a place someone sends you to in order to punish you. It is just the nature of hatred to produce hell, or the nature of hatred is hell. This is just how things are.

Sometimes people doubt the reality of hell. Even Buddhists sometimes think "it is just a state of mind. If its just mind then its not real, so it can't be that bad." However, while it is true that hell does not inherently exist, neither does this human life! If you experience this life as a reality, hell will be experiencedin the same way. For as long as there is negative karma, for as long as there is self-grasping, suffering is a real experience. Only when one attains enlightenment and realizes emptiness, one realizes that the realms, including the pure lands do not inherently exist.In addition, we can see the suffering of all realms in our world. There are humans who experience the suffering of hell and hungry spirits. What is the cause of all suffering? The cause of all suffering is self-grasping and the afflictive emotions arising from it.

Thus you should observe your own mind and if you find that you possess afflictive emotions such as anger, the result will certainly ripen in the future. Milarepa said, "The root of the lower realms is hatred, therefore practice patience even at the cost of your life." When you understand the suffering resulting from hatred, you will naturally wish to abandon it. If you do not understand this you may even mistakenly justify anger. From hatred arises hell, from greed appear the hungry spirits and from ignorance the animals. For instance, some people are unaware and destroy their life by drinking alcohol and taking drugs. This creates a propensity of ignorance leading to birth as an animal.There is outer and inner karma.

Outer karma refers to our external activities. One may think, “I am not killing, or stealing, I'm not doing anything wrong.” But what is more important is the inner karma. Even if one is not engaging in negative deeds externally, if one fails to give rise to compassion and only thinks about oneself, negative thoughts will accumulate in the mind like snowflakes falling continuously day and night. If we keep following the afflictive emotions, we will not find freedom for countless eons. That is only due to the actions we have committed based on this body. Karma, cause and effect, is infallible. ... 6903771388" onclick=";return false;

Posts: 1302
Joined: Sat Aug 13, 2011 2:05 am
Location: San Francisco, CA

Re: Garchen Rinpoche : The very nature of love is the Pure Land

Post by deepbluehum » Thu Jul 26, 2012 12:50 pm

This logic is dualistic, lower/upper. There is a sutta in the Pali canon where Buddha equates the brahma-vihara with the four formless attainments. But Garchen Rinpoche's logic doesn't even do that. It sounds more like if the afflictive emotions generate the lower realms, then love and compassion generate a form realm that looks like a land. If you have bodhichitta, which is distinct from compassion, then there is no Pure Land, according to him, because you have no self grasping. But then, if that's where the Buddhas are, then they are where there is no self grasping. How could there be and abode of Buddhas in a place with self-grasping and love? Makes no sense.

Post Reply

Return to “Tibetan Buddhism”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: pemachophel, Thomas Amundsen and 88 guests