Can foreigners ordain in China?
Can foreigners ordain in China?
Lately I've seen some pictures of both black and white monks in China. I know a lot of them actually ordain in Taiwan, and may perhaps go to the mainland. But I wonder if it is possible for a foreigner to ordain in mainland China and continue a monastic life there. Might anyone know? I suspect they may require first to obtain citizenship there.
nopalabhyate...
- Wesley1982
- Posts: 739
- Joined: Thu Mar 29, 2012 9:45 pm
- Location: Magga ~ Path to Liberation.
Re: Can foreigners ordain in China?
I'd say it depends on the rules of the instructors/teachers.
Re: Can foreigners ordain in China?
The short answer is "No".Dexing wrote:Lately I've seen some pictures of both black and white monks in China. I know a lot of them actually ordain in Taiwan, and may perhaps go to the mainland. But I wonder if it is possible for a foreigner to ordain in mainland China and continue a monastic life there. Might anyone know? I suspect they may require first to obtain citizenship there.
Again, no, it doesn't.Wesley wrote:I'd say it depends on the rules of the instructors/teachers.
~~ Huifeng
-
- Posts: 4209
- Joined: Mon Apr 06, 2009 4:21 am
- Location: California
Re: Can foreigners ordain in China?
It is possible for non-Chinese to ordain in the Chinese tradition outside China, but even that is not a simple affair.
May all seek, find & follow the Path of Buddhas.
Re: Can foreigners ordain in China?
Very true, Will. There are only a few of them / us.Will wrote:It is possible for non-Chinese to ordain in the Chinese tradition outside China, but even that is not a simple affair.
~~ Huifeng
- Wesley1982
- Posts: 739
- Joined: Thu Mar 29, 2012 9:45 pm
- Location: Magga ~ Path to Liberation.
Re: Can foreigners ordain in China?
Does this have to do with ordination to a Sangha order? if so, then I don't know.
Re: Can foreigners ordain in China?
I think what turns off a lot of non-Chinese is the fact they insist above all else you learn Mandarin (and learn it well) and attend a very long seminary program (three to four years and then they'll burn your head with incense) which includes elements really only relevant to Chinese culture. In effect, a lot of it won't be Dharma for liberation, but social etiquette, language classes and skills largely irrelevant outside the Chinese Buddhist cultural sphere. There are a lot of social expectations laid on Chinese monastics, too. You have to look and act the part.Will wrote:It is possible for non-Chinese to ordain in the Chinese tradition outside China, but even that is not a simple affair.
Ordination in a Tibetan or Theravada lineage also will probably provide a lot more freedom, albeit at the cost of not having guaranteed material support.
It isn't really hard to become a monk in a Chinese tradition, but it seems sticking around is most difficult for foreigners.
Re: Can foreigners ordain in China?
And the reason being what? Citizenship/visa issues?... anyway, I'd assume government?Huifeng wrote:The short answer is "No".Dexing wrote:Lately I've seen some pictures of both black and white monks in China. I know a lot of them actually ordain in Taiwan, and may perhaps go to the mainland. But I wonder if it is possible for a foreigner to ordain in mainland China and continue a monastic life there. Might anyone know? I suspect they may require first to obtain citizenship there.
My Chan master has been a monk in China since the mid-80's and is currently restoring a couple monasteries in another province and will take abbotcy/management of them. I'll bring this question up with him next time we meet.
In your organization, you must mean...Very true, Will. There are only a few of them / us.
nopalabhyate...
Re: Can foreigners ordain in China?
The basic reason is that non citizens cannot study at Buddhist colleges there, and in a way, really can't even live in the monasteries in the same way as the monastics (would have to be in a separate guest house, or equivalent).Dexing wrote:And the reason being what? Citizenship/visa issues?... anyway, I'd assume government?Huifeng wrote:The short answer is "No".Dexing wrote:Lately I've seen some pictures of both black and white monks in China. I know a lot of them actually ordain in Taiwan, and may perhaps go to the mainland. But I wonder if it is possible for a foreigner to ordain in mainland China and continue a monastic life there. Might anyone know? I suspect they may require first to obtain citizenship there.
Very few in this, or any other organization, by my count. Note, original point was "It is possible for non-Chinese to ordain in the Chinese tradition outside China, but even that is not a simple affair." Cf. Theravada, Zen, Tibetan traditions, etc.My Chan master has been a monk in China since the mid-80's and is currently restoring a couple monasteries in another province and will take abbotcy/management of them. I'll bring this question up with him next time we meet.
In your organization, you must mean...Very true, Will. There are only a few of them / us.
How many do you count? <-- not a rhetorical question, I really am curious.
~~ Huifeng
PS: I think the word you were looking for is "abbacy" (?).
Re: Can foreigners ordain in China?
That's odd...Huifeng wrote:The basic reason is that non citizens cannot study at Buddhist colleges there, and in a way, really can't even live in the monasteries in the same way as the monastics (would have to be in a separate guest house, or equivalent).
I don't have an exact count, but definitely more than a few. I've seen dozens of different white and black monks attending Dharma assemblies and events at monasteries in China right along with the Chinese monks. That's why I started this thread.How many do you count? <-- not a rhetorical question, I really am curious.
I also once saw two white and black "Hui" monks from FGS in Taiwan in a Chinese newspaper in the U.S.. I don't recall their names, but they were not you.
Dictionary.com lists "abbotcy" and "abbotship" as related forms of "abbot", so I chose one and went with it. But "abbacy" appears to be a valid form as well.PS: I think the word you were looking for is "abbacy" (?).
http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/abbot?s=t
nopalabhyate...
Re: Can foreigners ordain in China?
Sorry, by "few" I was thinking "no more than a few dozen". Again, relative to other traditions.
As for abbotcy - thank you, learnt something new today.
~~ Huifeng
As for abbotcy - thank you, learnt something new today.
~~ Huifeng
Re: Can foreigners ordain in China?
Thanks. I "learned" something too! (I thought you were originally American..?)Huifeng wrote:Sorry, by "few" I was thinking "no more than a few dozen". Again, relative to other traditions.
As for abbotcy - thank you, learnt something new today.
~~ Huifeng
nopalabhyate...
Re: Can foreigners ordain in China?
No, not American at all.Dexing wrote:Thanks. I "learned" something too! (I thought you were originally American..?)Huifeng wrote:Sorry, by "few" I was thinking "no more than a few dozen". Again, relative to other traditions.
As for abbotcy - thank you, learnt something new today.
~~ Huifeng
Not Taiwanese or Chinese, either.
~~ Huifeng
Re: Can foreigners ordain in China?
For those seeking monastic ordination in a traditional monastery of the Chinese tradition,
I can highly recommend the City of Ten Thousand Buddhas in California. Although the vast
majority of monastics are of Asian origin, the place has also produced several influential
Western monastics including Venerable Heng Sure and Venerable Heng Chih, who teaches
at a university in Australia.
The monastery is very traditional, includes rising early, the morning and evening recitations,
thorough Vinaya training for would be bhikshus and bhikshunis, classes and strict meditation
retreats. You will not get closer to a traditional style Chinese monastery in the Western world.
I can highly recommend the City of Ten Thousand Buddhas in California. Although the vast
majority of monastics are of Asian origin, the place has also produced several influential
Western monastics including Venerable Heng Sure and Venerable Heng Chih, who teaches
at a university in Australia.
The monastery is very traditional, includes rising early, the morning and evening recitations,
thorough Vinaya training for would be bhikshus and bhikshunis, classes and strict meditation
retreats. You will not get closer to a traditional style Chinese monastery in the Western world.